Is Vitani Scar's daughter?

[SummerSnowLeopard]

It is! Scar is Vitani's father! O.o

[Sasha]

Just thinking through my list of semi canon characters,
Is there any chance that Tojo could be the father? I mean, he has the same beautiful blue eyes, golden fur and nose color. Along with that he had on and off ear rims in the comics, like Vitani in the movie. The only thing that points away is that if Kovu and Vitani were from the same father, there wouldn't be much chance of Tojo being their dad. He would have to have more of a color scheme like Chuimvi's for the darker pelt, darker fur around the eyes etc..
Just my two cents (more like five dollars) worth

[HellmotherEva]

I think Scar is her father, I mean why not?
And to this questions:
- The blue eyes/pink nose/hair tuft: Did anybody here EVER heard something of recessive genes? My parents have both dark hair and my dad even have a darker skin, but I'm still pale and blond, and this also works with lions ;P
And maybe it was like that: Scar and Zira mated and Vitani "happened" and a very short time after that Zira mated with another male and so she had Kovu and Vitani in the same litter – This actually works.

[TheLionPrince]

Really? Some people still think Vitani and Nuka are Scar's cubs in the wake of Simba's Pride director Darrell Rooney's confirmation. Or we just haven't spread the word?

Here's the inside scoop as best as I can remember it. Zira was designed to be Scar's mate so that their son had a claim to rule the Pride. But Michael Eisner believe that would mean Kiara and Kovu would be cousins, which wasn't right to him. In the animal kingdom, that's not an issue but in the human world (which Eisner believes the Lion King is a metaphor for human behavior) it is a problem. So Zira's direct lineage was obscured to make her 'just a follower'. It was changed in the middle of production.

Best - Darrell.

Anyway, Vitani can still be Scar's daughter in your fanfiction, but it's pretty much confirmed she isn't since Zira isn't Scar's mate. And even without Rooney's statement, Vitani (in a deleted scene) calls Scar "Scar", and never refers to him as her father.

[SlayerOfLight]

I can't believe some people REALLY think Vitani is Scar's daughter Zira wasn't Scar's mate, just an mentally unstable fangirl with the obsession of avenging Scar's death. Kovu even said to Kiara that Scar wasn't his father, so most likely vitani had the same father as Kovu (which obviously wasn't Scar)

[Tora]

I'm going to say no on the fact that Scar is way to selfish to love another. He only cared about one thing; the throne. I really think that Scar just liked Zira as a friend and really cared about no one else so he named Kovu his heir. Overall I think that it was another father possibly a rouge.

[Kopalover]

If anything. Scar being Vitani's father in the timeline didn't make sense. Unless Kovu and Vitani are slightly older than Kiara. Scar died, then (Canon version, not my own) Fluffy/Kiara was born, beginning on SP. If Vitani was Scars daughter, then she would of have to be born in between Scars death and Kiara's first(?) ceremony. Which would make Kiara much younger then Kovu and Vitani. They seem about the same age in SP. If Vitani was Scars daughter, then she would be slightly larger than both Kovu and Kiara, and almost the size of Nuka.

In which, the timeline provided would not allow Vitani to be Scars daughter. Vitani would have had to be a rouge's daughter, or any subcanon.

[TheBlackCatCrossing]

No, I don't understand why people ask this question. If he was hers then Disney would have acknowledged it. I am not saying there is anything wrong with fanon/headcanon, but still.

[Regulus]

Suppose Vitani is Scar's daughter.

Then why would Kovu be Scar's heir?

[DGFone]

Suppose Vitani is Scar's daughter.

Then why would Kovu be Scar's heir?

Scar is a guy with a Napoleon complex. He wont accept having a daughter replace him. Must be a son, even if it's not his own.