If Not Scar, Who?

[SimbasGuard]

[quote="StarlightLioness"]the rogue would have had to have been a dead ringer for Scar. Especially if that same rogue fathered all three cubs. I mean, we can safely assume that whoever fathered Kovu was a dead ringer for Scar - the coloring and the features, even the eyes are all a Scar-clone, if better muscled.[/quote]

Maybe it was Scar's stunt double

[StarlightLioness]

[quote="SimbasGuard"][quote="StarlightLioness"]the rogue would have had to have been a dead ringer for Scar. Especially if that same rogue fathered all three cubs. I mean, we can safely assume that whoever fathered Kovu was a dead ringer for Scar - the coloring and the features, even the eyes are all a Scar-clone, if better muscled.[/quote]

Maybe it was Scar's stunt double [/quote]

One of the perks of the stuntee's contract!

[Jiirani]

Since Nuka was always sort of ignored by Zira, when if he had been Scars son, you'd think she would want to preserve his memory and treat his flesh and blood better than she did. I figured that Nuka was a rouges son, but was told from a young age that Scar was actually his father, but that's just my opinion.

[SummerSnowLeopard]

Hmmm, I'm sticking with my original beleif in Nuka being Scar's true son. After all, Capricornfox could be telling a lie for all we know. We can't really confirm that was she was saying was true...its just an interesting thought.

And, lol, two votes are tied xD

[Nitro]

I always thought Nuka was Scar's son and original heir but after seeing he was so "Nuka-ish," Scar pretty much disowned him from the throne and Zira figured Scar's loins (I always wanted to say that XD) couldn't produce an acceptable heir, so she tried with a rogue and had Vitani. Around the time she was born, Scar was killed and the Outlanders cast off and yadda yadda yadda, and she didn't want a female heir, so then she wanted to try again. I always thought Kovu's father was Chumvi (no, not our Chumvi) who escaped Scar when he was a cub when he was killing all the males and became a rogue since they have the same coloring and features. Actually, when I read the comics, the first thing I thought when I saw a cub Chumvi was "AHH KOVU CLONE!"

[SummerSnowLeopard]

I've always thought the same thing as you (when it comes to the Nuka and Scar thing).

How does Chumvi look like Kovu???

[PrincessKiara]

If it`s not Scar, it was probably a rogue.

Personally, I like the thought of Nuka being the son of Scar and Zira, their only cub. That`s just how I like to see it, though. I don`t really think Scar had cubs with Zira at all.

[SimbasGuard]

[quote="PrincessKiara"]I don`t really think Scar had cubs with Zira at all.[/quote]

That is also a very valid possibility, however if they did not have cubs I think Zira still had to be Scar's mate. I don't think Zira would have been that devoted to Scar if she had only been on of his subjects. and I'm sure Nuka would have seen Scar as a father figure, and I would think that Vitani and Kovu thought of him that way even thought they knew he was not there father.

[SummerSnowLeopard]

Yeah, I agree with you. I think that Nuka was the son of Scar, and that Vitani and Kovu came from a rogue.

[SilverSimba01]

I always believe that Nuka is Scar's son