Are Nuka and Vitani the cubs of Scar?

[Kianga]

I've never heard the theory that Chumvi could be Vitani and Kovu's father before but it's definitely an interesting one and better than having no idea at all who their father could've been.

[Amy43]

I'm not sure about Nuka. I always thought he was Scar's son. That explains why he is upset with Kovu. I heard that someone talked with the makers of the movie and they said none of them were his cubs. That doesn't surprise me. I also always thought Scar and Zira were a couple, but a lot of people are saying that she was just obsessed with him. I'm trying to think back to the movie think of any lines Zira says that proves they were a couple. I don't remember any lines though. I'm pretty sure that Vitani isn't his daughter because she looks to be the same age as Kovu, and he isn't Scar's son. And I also don't think she's his daughter because of the time period. I don't think Scar was alive long enough to be her father. I'm guessing they are about the age of Kiara.

[SilverSimba01]

hmm, I sort of has think on that question that if Nuka and Vitani be Scar's cubs, I always think that Nuka is Scar's cub but I don't know about Vitani

[Chumvikingpride]

Vitani would therefore be a rogue girl?

[FlipMode]

[quote="SilverSimba01"]hmm, I sort of has think on that question that if Nuka and Vitani be Scar's cubs, I always think that Nuka is Scar's cub but I don't know about Vitani[/quote]

Nah I think that if Scar was either of their fathers then we would have been told in the film. Like when Nuka says "Scar was not even his father." so I would that a bit odd if he himself was Scar's son. I mean my father is dead, but I never refer to him by his full name, it just does not feel right.

[Jiirani]

[quote="FlipMode"]Nah I think that if Scar was either of their fathers then we would have been told in the film. Like when Nuka says "Scar was not even his father." so I would that a bit odd if he himself was Scar's son. I mean my father is dead, but I never refer to him by his full name, it just does not feel right.[/quote]

Yeah, I don't think Scar was the father of any of them, as Vitani calls Scar 'Scar' in one of the deleted scenes, and like you just said Nuka refered to him as 'Scar' and Kovu just isn't his son, so I wouldn't believe any of them are, for those reasons and others, and i'm sorry about your father Flip =(

[atouchofgrace]

Look, if both Nuka and Vitani refer to Scar by his full name and no one says or even hints he's their father, it's because he's not.

[Nadra]

[quote="atouchofgrace"]Look, if both Nuka and Vitani refer to Scar by his full name and no one says or even hints he's their father, it's because he's not.[/quote]
Yeah, I guess you're right. If they were meant to be Scar's cubs, it would've been mentioned in the movie.
However, I often refer to my father by his name, so I think Nuka and Vitani might do so aswell.

[crystally]

[quote="FlipMode"][quote="SilverSimba01"]hmm, I sort of has think on that question that if Nuka and Vitani be Scar's cubs, I always think that Nuka is Scar's cub but I don't know about Vitani[/quote]

Nah I think that if Scar was either of their fathers then we would have been told in the film. Like when Nuka says "Scar was not even his father." so I would that a bit odd if he himself was Scar's son. I mean my father is dead, but I never refer to him by his full name, it just does not feel right.[/quote]

Actually, that line hinted that Nuka was Scar's son, I mean, why would he said that if he himself wasn't Scar's son? It's not that weird for kids or in this case, cubs, to refer to their parents by their name/nickname. And the fact that this family is the antagonist makes it even less weird. I bet they didn't bother teaching their cubs morals, or how to be polite, etc.

[atouchofgrace]

[quote="Jiirani"]One of my friends spoke to someone who worked on Simba's Pride and apparently none of the cubs were actually Scars[/quote]
If one person who worked on SP said it, I beleive it.