Is Vitani Scar's daughter?

[atouchofgrace]

French he said: your parents will be surprised at your weddings

Well, he couldn't be more obvious with that. In portuguese he said they had a crush on each other and some day they would fall in love and end up married.

[Chumvikingpride]

Which explains everything!

[atouchofgrace]

Which explains everything!

Yep. I got sad when I watched the original version!

[Golionking]

It's possible

[Nightwere]

A lioness can mate with more than one male and have a two cubs with different fathers. Kovu and Vitani being the same age doesn't mean anything at all.

[TheRoguePrince]

Indeed, Vitani is also not included in Nuka's derisive attitude toward Kovu for not being Scar's son...

[PiP]

Based on Vitanis looks, we can assume that her father had a golden fur.. so I think he was a rogue.

This is something I see a lot of but what we have to remember is that cubs can get their coloration from their ancestors. For example a gray and a white cat could have a tabby kitten if say, it's great grandfather was a tabby. So when we look at Mufasa's golden coat it would be safe to say that Scar could be carrying those genes even if he doesn't show them himself.

Personally I don't know who I think Vitatni's father is but I think the most important thing is to let our imaginations run wild and not to limit ourselves by colour or something as simple as nose shapes. Genetics are are complicated thing, two dark coloured parents doesn't necessarily mean a dark coloured cub

[Pixie]

Based on Vitanis looks, we can assume that her father had a golden fur.. so I think he was a rogue.

This is something I see a lot of but what we have to remember is that cubs can get their coloration from their ancestors. For example a gray and a white cat could have a tabby kitten if say, it's great grandfather was a tabby. So when we look at Mufasa's golden coat it would be safe to say that Scar could be carrying those genes even if he doesn't show them himself.

Personally I don't know who I think Vitatni's father is but I think the most important thing is to let our imaginations run wild and not to limit ourselves by colour or something as simple as nose shapes. Genetics are are complicated thing, two dark coloured parents doesn't necessarily mean a dark coloured cub

Exactly my point. Also, there may be lions out there who look similar to Scar what bred with Zira to make Kovu. Scar wouild'nt be the only one who looked that way.

[FlipMode]

Indeed, Vitani is also not included in Nuka's derisive attitude toward Kovu for not being Scar's son...

That is a good point actually, she does not even mention Scar in the film at all. I still personally do not see it though, these are the kinds of questions that if true then I think we would have been told about, but it is fun to speculate and theorise. But nothing clicks... There is no real sign that she would be, nor that she would not be as a matter of fact. I mean it does not even explain if she is Zira's daughter, because if she is then Zira being so obsessed with Scar is a bit strange, but if she is not then it makes more sense.

[Rarity]

I thought it was cannon that Vitani was scar's daughter