Is Vitani Scar's daughter?

[atouchofgrace]

Here's my opinion:

1 - We know Zira worships Scar and would die for him but I didn't see any scene implying Scar had the same feelings for her.
2 - I've never seen a single scene showing Zira and Scar as mates and having a daughter.
3 - Zira never said Scar is Vitani's daughter. Just because we don't know who the poor guy was, that doesn't mean it's Scar.
4 - Zira never said she was Scar's mate or she loved him romantically and they had a romantic/sexual relationship.
5 - In a deleted scene Vitani refers to Scar as "Scar", not "daddy", not "dad", not "father".
6 - Just because Vitani looks a bit like Scar (I don't see it but some people say she does), that doesn't mean she's his daughter.
7 - Zira was more likely to be obsessed with Scar. You can be obsessed with Michael Jackson but that doesn't mean your son is his son.

Is Vitani Scar's daughter? We'll never know but we don't have any kind of evidence to suggest she is.

[Chumvikingpride]

It's strange because it mentions scar as "Dad" in the French version...

[atouchofgrace]

[quote="Chumvikingpride"]It's strange because it mentions scar as "Dad" in the French version...[/quote]
Who? Vitani? If so, it's the french version.

From the deleted scene:
Nuka - "Who's she (Zira) talking to?
Vitani - Scar.

[Chumvikingpride]

[quote="atouchofgrace"][quote="Chumvikingpride"]It's strange because it mentions scar as "Dad" in the French version...[/quote]
Who? Vitani? If so, it's the french version.

From the deleted scene:
Nuka - "Who's she (Zira) talking to?
Vitani - Scar.[/quote]


Yes in the French version it mentions "Dad".
Should I look at the original version to better understand the film...

[atouchofgrace]

[quote="Chumvikingpride"]
Should I look at the original version to better understand the film...[/quote]

Tell me about it. I never knew Simba and Nala were betrothed before watching the original version.

[Chumvikingpride]

Yet it is clear ^^

[atouchofgrace]

[quote="Chumvikingpride"]Yet it is clear ^^[/quote]
Yes, but they changed Zazu's dialogue in my language: "Your parents will be thrilled, with you two flirting like that."

[Chumvikingpride]

in I just can't wait to be king?

[atouchofgrace]

[quote="Chumvikingpride"]in I just can't wait to be king?[/quote]
Yep, right before I Just Can't Wait to Be King.

(this is getting off-topic though...)

[Chumvikingpride]

[quote="atouchofgrace"][quote="Chumvikingpride"]in I just can't wait to be king?[/quote]
Yep, right before I Just Can't Wait to Be King.

(this is getting off-topic though...)[/quote]

Even a small off) topic then it is

French he said: your parents will be surprised at your weddings