Might Nuka Have Turned out to be Good?

[PrincessKiara]

I voted No.. Nuka wasn`t really evil, just crazy and desperate. I don`t think he would ever turn against his mother and join the Pridelanders.

[KopsTheTerminator]

Now that I think about it, he might have changed. I tried imagining the scene..

Zira: If you don't fight, then you'll die as well...

Nuka: What? But mother, Vitani is your daughter-- my sister!

Zira: There's no room for love! I'll do what I must, nobody will stand in my way!

Nuka: But you're already in love-- with Scar! Or was your obsession a lie all along?

Zira: ...

Nuka: So, I was right.. *joins Vitani in shame, and the Outsiders follow*

[TheRoguePrince]

oh, good point. There is always the chance he turns good.

[Nadra]

Now that I think about it, he might have changed. I tried imagining the scene..

Zira: If you don't fight, then you'll die as well...

Nuka: What? But mother, Vitani is your daughter-- my sister!

Zira: There's no room for love! I'll do what I must, nobody will stand in my way!

Nuka: But you're already in love-- with Scar! Or was your obsession a lie all along?

Zira: ...

Nuka: So, I was right.. *joins Vitani in shame, and the Outsiders follow*

Wow, I can imagine that happening! I really believe Nuka might have become "good".

[TheRoguePrince]

Is he really "evil" to begin with? He is being blinded by his desire for love and acceptance. He does not really at any time do anything bad with a reason of his own.

[Lauren]

Is he really "evil" to begin with? He is being blinded by his desire for love and acceptance. He does not really at any time do anything bad with a reason of his own.

That's true TRP. Nuka didn't really do anything bad with a horrible fate. He was just trying to impress Zira so much but it wasn't working out so well with him that eventually leads to his death. If he did survive during the ambush, maybe he would seen who his mother really is a make a dynamic change to himself in his life.

[xLilacVixenx]

It is possible he could turn to the good side, but I would have planned it differently. Perhaps he would have been betrayed by Zira and he realizes that the Pridelanders were right and joined them. So, if Nuka had lived, I suppose he could turn out good. (:

[TheRoguePrince]

Indeed, Zira is the only Outsider who really has evil intentions. The others just want to be guided and accepted. Nuka is the worst affected because he is forgotten by his own father and left to be nothing more than fodder. He just wants love and acceptance from someone.

[Pixie]

I rekon he would've, because of the reasons people have brought up. I never saw him as evil. He's goofy, and I rekon he didn't really care about the whole "avenge Scar" bizzo. All he wanted was to be leader. I think Vitani's change of heart would've changed him too.

[Whitelionesseyes]

I think he would have change... I'm almost sure