Is Vitani Scar's daughter?

[Nadra]

[quote="Amy43"][quote="Kianga"]Wow didn't realize that could happen.[/quote]
Neither did I! Could it be possible? But i'm still not sure if Scar was alive long enough. Maybe he was.[/quote]
Yes, it is possible - and isn't even very uncommon (among lions).
Hmm... Maybe Scar and Zira were having some kind of CYFTLT moment at the same time as Simba and Nala?

[TheRoguePrince]

perhaps, it is plausible.

[Lauren]

I would say yes. Since she oviously wasn't in the same situation that Kovu was in, Nuka and Vitani would have to be considered Scar's biological children. Kovu's the only one out of the three that isn't biological to Scar.

[xLilacVixenx]

It all depends on what you believe in; personally, I don't know.

[SuperBabySimba]

She can't be. She was obviously the same age as Kovu who is not Scar's son.

I'm going by the real life lion pride information, which I do believe Disney went by, otherwise it would've become too random:

Judging by his mane which had started to grow, Kovu must have been at least 1,5 years old in the beginning. Vitani and Kovu must be from the same litter or else Vitani ought to be bigger than Kovu. Lions carry the unborn cub for some 3+ months and don't have more cubs until the current litter is at least six months old as in when they don't nurse them anymore. Resulting in Vitani having to be at least 9 months older than Kovu if she isn't from the same litter, and that would make Vitani almost 2,5 years old which is about the time when lionessess usually start practice hunting and thus Vitani would have to be bigger.

EDIT:// And where is this "lion twins having different fathers isn't even uncommon among lions and it's possible anyway" coming from? I have never seen a nature document that would state that?

[Pixie]

Just because Vitani has slight similarities to Scar doesn't prove to me that she is Scar's daughter. There are other lions out there people!

[SummerSnowLeopard]

Vitani is Scar's daughter! duh.

[xLilacVixenx]

Why is there such a debate on who is Vitani's mother and father?

Getting back on subject, no, I don't believe he is. As I clearly stated in my other thread, Zira was more likely to be obsessed with Scar rather than his mate. It doesn't make much sense if they did marry. Thus, Zira must have had another mate who she had Vitani with. Besides, Vitani looks nothing like Scar.

[AdAstrα]

[quote="xLilacVixenx"]Why is there such a debate on who is Vitani's mother and father?

Getting back on subject, no, I don't believe he is. As I clearly stated in my other thread, Zira was more likely to be obsessed with Scar rather than his mate. It doesn't make much sense if they did marry. Thus, Zira must have had another mate who she had Vitani with. Besides, Vitani looks nothing like Scar.[/quote]
This.

[Chumvikingpride]

Nuka nor does resemble little scar and yet it is his son, and i think therefore that vitani's daughter