Did Scar Kill his Father Ahadi?

[Momotaro]

I personally think Ahadi died of old age.

Just my opinion, though.

[PrincessKiara]

^ That`s what I think too.

In my personal opinion, I think the relationship between Mufasa/Scar was worse than between Ahadi/Scar...
And anyway, like I said earlier, if Scar killed Ahadi, he still wouldn`t get to be king until he had killed Mufasa too. Scar seems to me as a cold and strategic guy, it just doesn`t make sense for him to do something that gains him nothing.

[PrinceTaka]

I don't think that Taka/Scar killed his own father or lead him to a trap and let the hyenas do the dirty work. It would not make sense because Mufasa would still been before him in the line of heritage. Ahadi simply died of old age.

[thelionking95]

just think what is the motive of scar for killing his own father..
just my opinion..Peace...

[PrincessKiara]

^ Exactly, that`s what I think too.

[TheRoguePrince]

Scar is still rational at this point, it would have been easier to get his brother killed first, if anything.

[Cantwait2bequeen]

I recall, from somewhere, that scar did kill his father- not as violently as Mufasa though- it was that he drank from a poisoned waterhole or something along those lines.... O_O

[TheRoguePrince]

That seems a bit brash for scar, the animals in the proximitiy would have shown signs of poisoning before Ahadi got there. It would be obvious.

[PrinceTaka]

[quote="Cantwait2bequeen"]I recall, from somewhere, that scar did kill his father- not as violently as Mufasa though- it was that he drank from a poisoned waterhole or something along those lines.... O_O[/quote]

If I remember right that "somewhere" was on TLKFAA. So only a fan-theory and nothing more.

But then again every guess on this thread is a fan-theory.

[SophieCub]

He died of old age I think..