by Gemini » August 26th, 2014, 12:12 am
Well, I came across this last night, before the site went down. And frankly I don't quite think you understand the implications of what you've posted or how it comes across. I know that you mean well and I understand the quote, but what you've said and how you've interpreted it seems absolutely insensitive to people who truly are suffering.
Yes. There are people who have it pretty well and complain idly. And yes, they're annoying. But there are plenty of people who suffer and are afraid to open up about their problems for this exact reason, because people always have something cutting to say along these exact lines. "Eh, you don't have it that bad, just cheer up". That might work for someone who's a little down, but for someone with serious depression...
I seriously hope that you never say this to someone who's depressed.
And when I say 'depression', I don't mean 'mild sadness'. I don't mean the sort that just comes for a day and goes away, like if it rains or your favorite show was canceled or you got a B+ on your report card. There is a serious, tangible pain. And it follows you. For days, weeks, even months. You can't just 'buck up'. It's a serious psychological condition and it causes a lot of problems.
Look at Robin Williams, for example. Does he qualify as "homeless" or "starving"? Absolutely not. And given his success and his outward disposition, I do not think he at all qualifies as someone who "wallowed in self-pity", as you put it. But look what happened to him. Why do you think that is?
It's because of this exact reaction. "Oh, but you're Robin Williams! The whole country loves you! You ain't suffered nothing, so shut up!"
Thing is, people have their reasons. And they're not really anybody's business. I know all this because I went through the same thing. It is not a path you want to go down. And I would never wish it upon anybody else.
And before you ask, no, I am not homeless. But we've been pretty damn close, not to mention that I've gone through plenty of other sh-t as well (I'm 16 and have already witnessed/had firsthand experience in a major way of death, divorce, mental illness, mental disability, loneliness, isolation, being poor... the list goes on).
Depressed people need understanding and they need to know that they're worth something. Tell them that they're strong enough to get through it, relate your story and tell them how you overcame it. Help them find their way. Don't minimize their problems. That sends absolutely the wrong message. I honestly hope that you never approach someone who's suicidal and say something like this. I know it might sound 'fine' or 'inspirational' to you but again, this does not come across as empathetic.
In short, if people are suffering, don't presume to know what they are going through. They might seem like they're 'fine' or are just pitying themselves but you don't know the sort of hell that might be going on behind the scenes. People hide those things for a reason. So either leave them be or try to ease their burden. Don't add on to it.