Is Nuka Scar's son?

[Wereberess]

[quote="Kopa23"]How would he be covered in dust? Vitani doesn't have that colour in that screengrab with Nuka and her.[/quote]

Because he doesn't bathe

[Wereberess]

[quote="redcelerity"][quote="Wereberess"][quote="redcelerity"]Nuka is not Scar's son why not take a look at Kuvo he is smart, he is stronger and heck why would Nuka even relate to Scar? they arent really that similar, idd say Kuvo and Scar is a greater match, but Kuvo isnt his son. and if you read my earlier comments on Page 3 you'll see why i dont believe it.[/quote]

It's spelled "Kovu" not "Kovo"
Just so you know
Also Kovu only looks like Scar colorwise. Maybe you should take a look at their builds.
Nuka however resembles Scar colorwise AND build wise, even those his fur has a grayish tint to it, thanks to Zira's tan gray fur.[/quote]

Okay, if we look at builts, maybe BUT! built doesnt decide a damn thing!, a not very fat, sorry rather want to use big, a small person can give birth to one that is big what i refer to is that maybe Nuka is only built like that because he was born that way, so what your saying is that if your parent is of a physically large built you cant be related to them because your small??[/quote]

If your parents are well built them unless you were premature you'd be well built as well.
And yes...build does decide alot. If both you parents are lanky you WILL be lanky unless you just over eat or something and that's clearly not possible if you live in thoutlands.

[Wereberess]

Check this out!
Nuka looks ALOT like Scar here!

[SnowyCheetah]

[quote="Wereberess"][quote="Kopa23"]How would he be covered in dust? Vitani doesn't have that colour in that screengrab with Nuka and her.[/quote]

Because he doesn't bathe [/quote]

How would anyone know if he bathes or not?

[Wereberess]

[quote="SnowyCheetah"][quote="Wereberess"][quote="Kopa23"]How would he be covered in dust? Vitani doesn't have that colour in that screengrab with Nuka and her.[/quote]

Because he doesn't bathe [/quote]

How would anyone know if he bathes or not?[/quote]

Because out of alll the outlanders he seemed to be most unkempt.

[redcelerity]

Wereberes; It's spelled "Kovu" not "Kovo"
Just so you know
Also Kovu only looks like Scar colorwise. Maybe you should take a look at their builds.
Nuka however resembles Scar colorwise AND build wise, even those his fur has a grayish tint to it, thanks to Zira's tan gray fur.[/quote]

Me; Okay, if we look at builts, maybe BUT! built doesnt decide a damn thing!, a not very fat, sorry rather want to use big, a small person can give birth to one that is big what i refer to is that maybe Nuka is only built like that because he was born that way, so what your saying is that if your parent is of a physically large built you cant be related to them because your small??[/quote]

Wereberes; If your parents are well built them unless you were premature you'd be well built as well.
And yes...build does decide alot. If both you parents are lanky you WILL be lanky unless you just over eat or something and that's clearly not possible if you live in thoutlands.[/quote]

Me; Okay so you actually say my brother arent related to me? my parents is a little chubby and my brother...
well you can see his bones, so how does built decide that?!, built of the parents doesnt decide a damn thing, my bone structure is bigger than my parents aswell, but im not fat im rather skinny..

[Annie]

I agree with redcelerity, I look totally different to my brothers, my dad AND my mum. Only similar thing is that my mum has brown hair/eyes and so do I, other than that, we don't look related.

Though, I'm 50/50 about Nuka being Scars son...I dunno, so many reasons he should be, so many he shouldn't be.

[SophieCub]

I think he is because in TLK II He was talking about Scar and Kovu and he said," Scar just took him in" So if he wasn't his real son he couldn't say that.

[Simba]

I agree with redcelerity and Annie. your parents build doesn't necessarily determine yours. there's lots of other build genes inherited from grandparents as well that can miss a generation (or a few more maybe) and come out in a later generation. plus, the environment and diet also have a major affect. someone could have the genetics to have a large build, but due to illness or malnutrition at the developing stage (childhood, early adolescence) end up much smaller than what DNA intended. and given the conditions in the Outlands, this could very well have occured to Nuka for all we know.

[quote="SimbaCub"]I think he is because in TLK II He was talking about Scar and Kovu and he said," Scar just took him in" So if he wasn't his real son he couldn't say that.[/quote]

yes he could've lol. he was just complaining about how Kovu was the heir when he wasn't even Scar's son. that doesn't mean Nuka is.

[Kojo]

I've never really thought that Nuka was Scar's own son. I'd always assumed that his resentment towards Kovu was based on his being the eldest and being passed up as the heir for the younger male. Zira states that Kovu was the last cub born before the Outlanders were exiled from the Pridelands. That being true, Nuka, being older, could have actually known Scar while Kovu never met the lion (that he can remember). That, too, would add to his resentment of not being chosen.

And if Nuka was Scar's biological son, then I don't understand why Scar would have chosen another cub who he didn't sire to be his heir in the first place. Scar was obsessed with leaving a legacy, with being the greatest king ever. And he was nutso. There's no reason why he wouldn't want his bloodline to continue to be royal, even if he thought Kovu might have been smarter than Nuka.

Saying that Scar passed up Nuka in place of Kovu because Nuka was weak doesn't hold water with me either. We only see Nuka as a young adult, well after it's known that he is not the Chosen One. Kovu is well cared for as a cub and young adult because of his value to the Outlanders. Nuka didn't get so much care, so of course he would be unkempt, skinny, and look weaker than he would've been otherwise.