Is Nuka Scar's son?

[Wereberess]

[quote="parabuteo78"]Just think about this; would Zira chose Kovu to become king, if Nuka truely was Scar's son?
I mean, wouldn't she want an actual descendant of her beloved Scar to defeat her nemesis and take his place in the Pride Lands, instead of a non-related cub?[/quote]

Firstly, Zira didn't choose Kovu. Scar did.

And if Zira was Scar's obsessed fangirl she would go along with him on anything. Scar didn't want Nuka as his heir and since Kovu looked enough llike himself he chose Kovu.

[Wereberess]

[quote="Simba"]but when he says "I'm the oldest, I'm the strongest, I'm the smartest," wouldn't that be the perfect opportunity to mention that Scar was his father as yet another reason why he deserved to be the choosen one? he didn't mention that.

plus the only similarities to Scar he has are an angular nose with a hooked nose pad, extremely common in all Outlanders, a blackish mane which again isn't all that unusual, and a lanky build that again all Outlanders pretty much have and most likely results from their lack of food in the Outlands.

all Nuka was saying in that line was that Kovu wasn't Scar's son. it doesn't mean that he is instead. besides, Nuka doesn't really associate himself with Scar at all in the movie, he wants to be leader because he thinks he's more capable. he even remarked "Yugh" when Zira was talking about how Scar's coniving mind made him powerful.[/quote]

I think when he says oldest, strongest and smartest he means he was the firstborn heir, and he has more experience in leading hence the phrase "I could be a leader if she'd just give me a chance."

Nuka has dark eyeshades like Scar, dark fur like Scar, a black mane like Scar, a black nose like Scar. Nuka IS Scar pretty much. And all outsiders don't have a Scar shaped nose and dipped nose bridge.
Acually the pridelander nose is more common in Zira's pride.

Why would Nuka complain about Kovu if he wasn't Scar's son himself. He wouldn't even have a reason to complain. I'd believe you if Nuka had said "Kovu, Kovu, Kovu. He wasn't even firstborn." but he didn't

There really no reason to not believe Nuka is Scar's father.

[redcelerity]

Okay Does everyone here ignore the fact that Kovu also looks like Scar and looks more like him?, he even has the scar, Nuka isnt his son, and by that i really mean it, because if Nuka really was Scar's son then what about Kuvo?, same skin, same mane, same eye color, even gets the very same scar!, and yet still you persists in thinking Nuka is the son of Scar, what about the fact that Kovu looks so much like Scar, and yet he isnt related?, ever thought if it was the same with Nuka?, and that he was just being jelous of Kuvo because he can win over him in a fight?

[thanigraphics]

Nuka has a few sayings in the first scene where he appears that make sure for me he IS Scars son. The reason Kovu was the Chosen One instead of Nuka is obvious. I think they made Nuka ’crazy’ is because for the plot it wouldn´t be great if Kiara started dating Scars son....they would get Nuka-ish babies

[redcelerity]

[quote="thanigraphics"]Nuka has a few sayings in the first scene where he appears that make sure for me he IS Scars son. The reason Kovu was the Chosen One instead of Nuka is obvious. I think they made Nuka ’crazy’ is because for the plot it wouldn´t be great if Kiara started dating Scars son....they would get Nuka-ish babies [/quote]
Does he say that he is the son of scar? no, why wouldnt he say something like "i should be the leader since im a true decendant of scar." etc?

[KopsTheTerminator]

[quote="Wereberess"]Nuka has dark eyeshades like Scar, dark fur like Scar, a black mane like Scar, a black nose like Scar. Nuka IS Scar pretty much. And all outsiders don't have a Scar shaped nose and dipped nose bridge.[/quote]

Actually, seeing Simba's reply made me change my mind about his appearance..

Nuka's fur isn't even close to Scar's. That image I have in the first post is from the original SP. Zira has a black nose, and he could have inherited his black mane from Zira's side of the family. Plus, if he really is Scar's son, why is he so much weaker than him and why does he has the IQ of a digested oyster? Actually, that's like saying all the Outsiders are related to Scar lol..

[Wereberess]

[quote="Kopa23"][quote="Wereberess"]Nuka has dark eyeshades like Scar, dark fur like Scar, a black mane like Scar, a black nose like Scar. Nuka IS Scar pretty much. And all outsiders don't have a Scar shaped nose and dipped nose bridge.[/quote]

Actually, seeing Simba's reply made me change my mind about his appearance..

Nuka's fur isn't even close to Scar's. That image I have in the first post is from the original SP. Zira has a black nose, and he could have inherited his black mane from Zira's side of the family. Plus, if he really is Scar's son, why is he so much weaker than him and why does he has the IQ of a digested oyster? Actually, that's like saying all the Outsiders are related to Scar lol..[/quote]

Firstly the characters true colors are shown in plain daylight. The picture YOU have is in the outlands where everything is lighter in color. In the elephant graveyards Nuka's fur color looks VERY similar to Scar's if not the excact same shade.

Lions cannot inherit mane colors. Never proven. And just because your parents are smart doesn't mean you are going to be(Besides. Zira was more insane than smart.)

PS: i know where you got the digested oyster joke...

[rich198]

I reckon he is scars son. the reason why Kovu may have been chosen over Nuka maybe that Zeira and Scar didt want the cosen one Kovu to be directly related to Simba. so by Kovu only being Zeiras son rather than scars aswell he isnt directly linked to Simba. but Nukas looks and jealousy strongly suggestb he is Scars son

[KopsTheTerminator]

[quote="Wereberess"]Firstly the characters true colors are shown in plain daylight. The picture YOU have is in the outlands where everything is lighter in color. In the elephant graveyards Nuka's fur color looks VERY similar to Scar's if not the excact same shade.[/quote]

How? Nuka's colour looks more like blue when he's at the Elephant Graveyard. Scar's looks more like green and dark grey. Plus, even if the colours match, it doesn't change the fact that in the daylight their fur colours are different. Even SIMBA could get in there and get the same dark colour.

[Eli_Ayase]

The colors really dont match each other