Is Vitani Scar's daughter?

[TheRoguePrince]

Vitani is more akin to Nuka than Kovu, besides, Kovu is definately not Scar's son.

[LionKing4EVR96]

I think she might be, but for sure I believe Nuka is Scar's son.

[Amy43]

I sort of believe that Vitani is Scar’s daughter. I do believe that both Nuka and Vitani look like the cubs of Scar and Zira. I have a couple big questions! Was Scar alive long enough to be the father of both Nuka AND Vitani?? If he was, wouldn’t there be more of an age difference between Vitani, Kovu, and Kiara? And also, since Vitani and Kovu appear to be the same age, wouldn’t they be in the same litter? That wouldn’t make sense, because we already know that Scar is not Kovu’s father. If Scar is Vitani’s father, wouldn’t that mean that Zira is not Kovu’s mother, and we don’t know who either of his parents are? I’m a little confused!

[PrinceTaka]

I don't really see any reason why Vitani's father would anyone else but Scar. About the "blue eyes discussion" I have to say that blue eyes are recessive and both parents have to have the genes for it and pass them on, if not both pass their blue-eye-genes on the dominant genes (brown) will win. So Scar with green eyes also has genes for blue eyes and also Zira has genes for blue eyes. But if both would have blue eyes, Vitani would also have blue eyes, unless there would be some mutation in her genes.

I know it's like this in the real life but why not also in TLK?

[Kianga]

In my theory at least, Kovu and Vitani are twins since they appear to be the same age in the movie. Since Scar is not Kovu's father, he wouldn't be Vitani's father either.

[AdAstrα]

I'm not sure..I also think Vitani appeared to be the same age as Kovu =/

[Nadra]

[quote="Amy43"]I sort of believe that Vitani is Scar’s daughter. I do believe that both Nuka and Vitani look like the cubs of Scar and Zira. I have a couple big questions! Was Scar alive long enough to be the father of both Nuka AND Vitani?? If he was, wouldn’t there be more of an age difference between Vitani, Kovu, and Kiara? [/quote]
I guess so. Or maybe Zira's pregnancy was extra long (and Kovu & Vitani were small for their age).

[quote="Amy43"]And also, since Vitani and Kovu appear to be the same age, wouldn’t they be in the same litter? That wouldn’t make sense, because we already know that Scar is not Kovu’s father. If Scar is Vitani’s father, wouldn’t that mean that Zira is not Kovu’s mother, and we don’t know who either of his parents are? I’m a little confused![/quote]
Even human twins can have different fathers, so why not lion twins too?

[QueenRalexia]

I think that Vitani's father is most likely Scar, I also think she was born in the Pridelands probably during Scar's Reign and exiled soon after Simba returned. But thats just my opinion

[Kianga]

[quote="Nadra"]
Even human twins can have different fathers, so why not lion twins too?[/quote]

Wow didn't realize that could happen.

[Amy43]

[quote="Kianga"][quote="Nadra"]
Even human twins can have different fathers, so why not lion twins too?[/quote]

Wow didn't realize that could happen.[/quote]
Neither did I! Could it be possible? But i'm still not sure if Scar was alive long enough. Maybe he was.