Is Vitani Scar's daughter?

[Carl]

I believe Scar was already dead when Kovu and Vitani were conceived as they appear to be the same age as Kiara. Therefore, Scar had nothing to do with either of the cubs; certainly he didn't sire them. And people keep mentioning the fact that Kovu was Scar's heir- to this I say, is it not possible that Zira merely saw the resemblance to Scar in Kovu and lied to the others, saying that he was hand-picked by Scar, so that the others would let her cub be the king? Her cub that looked remarkably like the object of her obsession?

I highly doubt Scar would have had any children, and if he did, they would be older than Vitani. So no. I don't think she is his daughter.

[UncoordinatedPisces]

[quote="Juliette"]I believe Scar was already dead when Kovu and Vitani were conceived as they appear to be the same age as Kiara. Therefore, Scar had nothing to do with either of the cubs; certainly he didn't sire them. And people keep mentioning the fact that Kovu was Scar's heir- to this I say, is it not possible that Zira merely saw the resemblance to Scar in Kovu and lied to the others, saying that he was hand-picked by Scar, so that the others would let her cub be the king? Her cub that looked remarkably like the object of her obsession?

I highly doubt Scar would have had any children, and if he did, they would be older than Vitani. So no. I don't think she is his daughter.[/quote]

That's an interesting theory ^.^ I'm unsure, I'm sure I'll let my imagination decide one day.

[Khanu]

She certainly looked like a smaller female version of him, without the scar lol. She also seemed to share his evil charisma and personality. I would say that she is the daughter of Scar. As for her mother? Well, I think it's probably Zira. Or maybe another pride lioness

[Tora]

We know for a fact that Zira is Vitani's mother; considering Vitani herself calls Zira mother. It's the father really at question and Kovu says that Scar isn't his father which leads me to believe that he is also not Vitani's father.

[Kopalover]

It's possible that she could be, but the timeline given provides the answer. Vitani would have had to be much older than she was if she was Scar's daughter.

[Tabby]

I actually think Scar's Vitani's father, I mean, why would Nuka remark HER how Kovu is not son of Scar?, woulnd't he instead have mention how they both aren't Scar's relatives. I don't see why should Vitani be older, I mean, if Scar was alive when he chose Kovu, why couldn't even Zira be pregnant of Scar in that moment?, I never heard anything saying Vitani was obligatory YOUNGER than Kovu, but still that's not the point, during the exile she could've been a cub anyways, a baby, maybe, I woulnd't know, but I think it's more probably that she's Scar's daughter

[SlayerOfLight]

Vitani isn't scar's daughter, it has not been confirmed by the TLK creators. Only in the world of ''fanfiction'' can she be scar's daughter.

[Tabby]

So only in the world of "fanfiction" can she be anyone else's daughter :B

[Khanu]

Fanfiction means you can have anything. I could write a fanfiction that has humans in TLK, but that doesn't mean they are canon lol

[SlayerOfLight]

exactly, because Zira never said Vitani is Scar's daughter. And Kovu even said Scar wasn't his father, so Vitani's father couldn't be Scar. (except in fanfiction, where everything is possible)