Is Nala Vitani's real mother?

[TheIvanMuse]

Guys,you think too much about this. Vitani is Zira's daughter,it's implied to in the movie,case closed. And Nala was certainly not raped by Scar,get your mind out of the gutter.

[Chumvikingpride]

It is when even Zira is the mother of vitani... almost identical colour, carbonaceous the Outlander eyes, thin and long, nose....

[Miharuka]

I'm sure Nala isn't Vitani's mother.

And bytheway, Vitani has more like a purple nose, right?
And Nala's nose is more like..pink/red , dark pink? xD

And IF she would have gotten Vitani with Scar then Vitani must be older, right? Well ofcourse I don't know how old Simba and Nala were when Kiara was born but... xD They look some older though, so..
And in the beginning from the movie she's still a cub like Kiara.
Sorry if someone said this already. ^^''

I think it's easy to explain it's obvius Nala isn't Vitani's mother.
Vitani have looks from Zira also in my opinion. I don't see any of Nala to be fair.

[Chumvikingpride]

I do not think zira will accept a small of nala... apart if scar is the father, but it's me astonished

[atouchofgrace]

Here's my opinion:

1 - Just because Vitani looks a bit like Nala, that doesn't mean she's her daughter.
2 - In TLK, Simba and Nala are very young (around 17/18/19 years old). How do I know? Some script drafts refer to what we call adult Simba and adult Nala as adolescent Simba and adolescent Nala in the same exact scenes we have today in the movie.
3 - Originally, Nala (and, at some point, Sarabi) was going to be seduced (not raped) by Scar but that scene (and other scenes from Scar's reign) got cut.
4 - Why would Nala sleep with Scar? Nala despises Scar. Nala loves Simba.
5 - Vitani calls Zira "mother".
6 - Zira raised Vitani.
7 - I've never seen a single scene showing Scar having sex with Nala, getting her pregnant and Nala giving birth to Vitani and calling her "daughter".
8 - The only thing Vitani says to Nala is "Where is your pretty daughter, Nala?" not "I am your pretty daughter, Nala."
9 - The only thing Nala says to Vitani is "Vitani!" not "My child!"
10 - Next thing they do is fight each other.

Is Vitani Nala's daughter? No.

[Miharuka]

^ And THAT explains everything. :]

[TheIvanMuse]

[quote="atouchofgrace"]Here's my opinion:

1 - Just because Vitani looks a bit like Nala, that doesn't mean she's her daughter.
2 - In TLK, Simba and Nala are very young (around 17/18/19 years old). How do I know? Some script drafts refer to what we call adult Simba and adult Nala as adolescent Simba and adolescent Nala in the same exact scenes we have today in the movie.
3 - Originally, Nala (and, at some point, Sarabi) was going to be seduced (not raped) by Scar but that scene (and other scenes from Scar's reign) got cut.
4 - Why would Nala sleep with Scar? Nala despises Scar. Nala loves Simba.
5 - Vitani calls Zira "mother".
6 - Zira raised Vitani.
7 - I've never seen a single scene showing Scar having sex with Nala, getting her pregnant and Nala giving birth to Vitani and calling her "daughter".
8 - The only thing Vitani says to Nala is "Where is your pretty daughter, Nala?" not "I am your pretty daughter, Nala."
9 - The only thing Nala says to Vitani is "Vitani!" not "My child!"
10 - Next thing they do is fight each other.

Is Vitani Nala's daughter? No.[/quote]

We have a winner.

[Chumvikingpride]

It is clear, bravo!

[Eli_Ayase]

TANI IS NOT NALAS DAUGHTER! Cos she is more to zira!

[atouchofgrace]

^^ Of course she's not. Vitani calls Zira "mother". If that's not proof that Zira is Vitani's mother, then I don't know what is.
If Zira is Vitani's mother, Vitani's mother can't be Nala.