Is Vitani Scar's daughter?

[Meskhenet]

I think Vitani is Scar's daughter but she resembles more towards Zira.

[TheBlackCatCrossing]

I have noticed that younger fans like to believe that Vitani is Scar's.

[SlayerOfLight]

[quote="TheBlackCatCrossing"]I have noticed that younger fans like to believe that Vitani is Scar's.[/quote]

This.

when will people ever learn Scar isn't Vitani's father >< Even Kovu said so in the movie, that Scar wasn't his father at all, neither does Zira even say she was Scar's mate. Young people can be so gullable at times...

[KopsTheTerminator]

No, she is not.

/thread

[Vitanibaby]

[quote="Kops"]No, she is not.

/thread[/quote]

Dat.

[MooLion]

It never really crossed my mind that she could be his daughter. Dunno how it would work with the time frames if the final cut suggested that Vitani was only a wee bit older than Kovu. But then if Scar hand-picked Kovu... Argh! Time frame confuses.

[Nadra]

[quote="Nicholas"][quote="TheBlackCatCrossing"]I have noticed that younger fans like to believe that Vitani is Scar's.[/quote]

This.

when will people ever learn Scar isn't Vitani's father >< Even Kovu said so in the movie, that Scar wasn't his father at all, neither does Zira even say she was Scar's mate. Young people can be so gullable at times...[/quote]

Well, Kovu said that Scar wasn't his father but he didn't say anything about Vitani. Zira didn't say she was Scar's mate - but she didn't say she wasn't, either.

But still, I think that Scar is not officially Vitani's father. However, people are free to have their "theories" ...

[SlayerOfLight]

[quote="Nadra"][quote="Nicholas"][quote="TheBlackCatCrossing"]I have noticed that younger fans like to believe that Vitani is Scar's.[/quote]

This.

when will people ever learn Scar isn't Vitani's father >< Even Kovu said so in the movie, that Scar wasn't his father at all, neither does Zira even say she was Scar's mate. Young people can be so gullable at times...[/quote]

Well, Kovu said that Scar wasn't his father but he didn't say anything about Vitani. Zira didn't say she was Scar's mate - but she didn't say she wasn't, either.

But still, I think that Scar is not officially Vitani's father. However, people are free to have their "theories" ...[/quote]

then again, nothing has ever been proven or confirmed that Scar was Vitani's father. By Kovu saying Scar wasn't his father, just plain simply means that Scar also isn't Vitani's father (unless in people's imagination of course, where they start making up their own ''facts'' such as that Zira never said she didn't have a second mate, and that Scar could be Vitani's father, like you just said)

and those ''theories'' are not true, neither are they facts, unless confirmed by the creators themselves. Some people just WANT their theories to be true, even if it's false. I'm sure if Vitani was REALLY Scar's daughter, the creators would have made that clear in the movie themselves.

Sorry, but you can't argue against this. Just get over it, Vitani isn't Scar's daughter.

[DGFone]

For all we know, Vitani might be Scar's daughter. The only thing is confirmed is that Kovu is not Scar's son, and Nuka is. So here already, we know that Nuka and Kovu are half-brothers. This could easily mean that Vitani is a half-sister to one or both of them.

[SlayerOfLight]

Nuka isn't Scar's son. On what evidence is your statement based? Just because Nuka looks like Scar, doesn't mean he really is Scar's son. Only in fanfiction can Nuka be Scar's son, or Vitani be Scar's daughter.