hey, i saw this topic had a thought, not sure if anyone said anything like this but forgive me for not reading every post. ( i'm just fairly tired right now and want to get this out before i go to bed)
I like the idea of tiering the rp's but i think it could be to the rp section's advantage to have 3 seperate rp user groups for members. judging not by the role play but by the member who is playing. now this sounds a bit confusing at first but lets see if i can explain it a bit.
My idea was that if you not only separated the rp's into a three tier system but also separated those who participate in them as well, the people who truly care about role playing and won't just drop out will advance in ranks.
MOTHER SHIP GUIDE IS A GREAT WAY TO SEE HOW IT SHOULD BE DONESo, how to separate them, well that's simple enough
1. Beginner
The beginner group should be open for all members to join, they are able to post in the beginner role play planning and the beginner role play forum and VIEW the intermediate and advanced(how are you supposed to learn if you can't see what you're supposed to be doing

). If they wish to go up in rank they have to prove to one of the staff members they can handle intermediate role playing by being active in a role play and they should not just be spitting out one liner's left and right.
2. Intermediate
Okay so these members have all proven to the staff that they are capable of being an active member of an intermediate role play. They should be able to see both Beginner and Intermediate planning and playing forums. The same rules apply if they want to be part of an advanced role play they need to contact a staff member and show a role play that shows they are fully capable of doing so.
3. Advanced
Now advanced members are of the highest rank, they should be watched carefully not only by the moderators but by there fellow rp members in order be absolutely sure that their posts are of the highest quality
Now i also think that members should be able to be demoted back down ranks if they join an rp, and break one of the common courtesies of role playing (taking a main role then going inactive) but they should always be able to prove themselves again, and there should be a three strike system.
one strike = verbal warning from usergroup leader
two strikes= a second warning and a notification to staff
three strikes = demotion in role play ranking
Personally i think this idea could use some expansion and i'm eagerly awaiting to see everyones opinion and i think it could really work but i have one last thought, if the staff made certain ACTIVE MATURE role players the leaders of the group it could take some pressure off the staff. ( this way the staff doesn't have to view every request to increase in rank, Kind of like RP mods except not moving threads.)
Thanks for reading it, and hopefully i'll get some good feed back.