Do you think if Nuka lived

[KiarasBiggestFan]

That he'd join the Pridelands or stay loyal to Zira?

[KingCub]

You know...This one is kinda a tough one!

My first thought was that we would stay loyal, as that is what his main goal in life was. He did a good job of it, as he died loyal.

But, then I got to thinking about his personality. He just wants to make people happy. And I feel that if Zira died, he would stick with him family and join the pridelands. He just seems like the kind of person to do that, and I could even see him becoming a leader in the group, alongside Simba and Kovu.

Its just hard for me to ever imagine him going against the outsiders if Zira was still around, but when she is gone I think he would follow his family.

[Claws]

I'd go with him staying outsider, maybe with a fate close to Zira's, since by then I think Zira pretty much had brainwashed him with hate and also I think he'd break in anger when he saw Zira dying... So being Scar and Zira's purpose, I think he'd stick with the plan, and try to kill Simba. Then again, I wouldn't be completly sure, since all the poor guy wanted was acceptance, it's just the matter realizing he'd that with the pride, or not.

[Carl]

I think he would probably stay loyal to the end. I actually think he would have gone down the cliff after Zira to try and help her or finish off Kiara, or both. When she died, he probably would have been distraught and angry and he'd probably go into a rage and blindly attack first Kiara and then Simba if he survived past attacking Kiara or helping Zira.

[Tora]

Honestly I don't think he would have remained loyal. He wanted to be accepted somewhere. All he ever knew was what his mother told him of Simba much like Kovu and Vitani; however I believe he would have turned seeing his brother and sister change sides. If we look back to the story we can see that in reality it was Zira that was the one who was trying to brain wash her whole pride. As all the other lioness' turned on Zira when Vitani turned we can see that the lioness' then viewed Zira as crazy. I mean if it wasn't apparently obvious already to them. I do often wonder if there wasn't a connection between Scar and Zira. Perhaps Zira was one of Scar's lioness he favored and that caused her to have a lot of influence on the pride when Simba came over to take back his crown. A lot of us believe that Scar was somehow involved with Zira, but no one really knows for sure. Overall I think that Nuka would have changed sides upon seeing both his brother and sister change sides.

[Regulus]

Nuka only wanted attention. I could see him switching sides faster than Kovu ever did.

[Bloodspill]

Wow, really? Every time I watch this movie, I get the impression that Nuka didn't care about anyone's attention but his mother. He didn't really care about Scar I think, but did what Zira said just to prove he's worth her attention, etc. He hated Simba, and hated KOVU. He would break down after Zira's death, jump after her into the river, I don't know. Don't forget he wasn't good character. Guess he'd rather run away...He wasn't that brave (remember Elephant Graveyard scene?) so maybe he wouldn't be able to make up his mind whose side to take.

[Carl]

I'm pretty sure if he hadn't died when he does in the film that he would have died with Zira in the final showdown. Proving himself to her was his number one goal.

[KentuckyWildcat]

Nuka wanted his mother's approval more than anything. In particular, he resented all the attention she lavished on the "Chosen One" Kovu at his expense. With Kovu changing sides, Nuka would have almost certainly attempted to seize the opportunity to be the hero (at least in Zira's eyes) and earn the validation that he so desperately sought.

That's actually a pretty similar to the scenario that led to his death in the actual events of the film. I just don't think that living to see the prides unite would have changed his perspective any.

[juhouh]

Nope. Nuka wanted to be a king so bad and he would have killed his stepbrother Kovu just like Scar did to Mufasa