by Panpardus » October 15th, 2016, 4:15 am
I have to agree with Nilla; outside of my own desires for this show, as nice as the episodes have been so far, it'll be cool and beneficial to have a show aimed at younger children that actually starts to develop a series-long plot with multi-dimensional characters. Most of these episodes have so far been pretty insular; only about three or four at most (including Return of the Roar) have given some actual plot development in the greater story arc while the others are more or less just miscellaneous adventures. The way I see it, because the creators have at least gone through the trouble of placing Kion's story in such a specific point within an already-established setting, there's got to be some narrative arc that they need to build toward; the show isn't going to last forever (especially since the live-action film is going to be a thing in a few years and I see it as weird having these two story universes -- produced by the same company -- being aired concurrently) and it's going to have to have a satisfying finish for as large a swath of the audience as possible.
As far as the moral nuance, so far virtually every character in The Lion Guard has been portrayed as solidly good or bad, not so much by their actions but rather what "side" they're on. It's literally stated in at least a few episodes that Kion and his Guard are good by definition, and I have yet to see any of the major antagonists explicitly given a real reason for their actions, let alone a sympathetic or compelling reason. For instance, we can read into the situation that Janja and co. are primarily driven by hunger, but Jasiri's episode singles them out as just being disrespectful jerks who hunt for fun and couldn't give a flying [$@%^#] about the circle of life or maintaining some natural order. Makuu is clearly power-hungry, but everything he does as an antagonist after his first appearance is kind of "just because"; for instance, what is his motivation for taking over the flood plains in "Never Roar Again"? He made such a big scene (totally un-crocodilian if you ask me) and chased away all the other animals that he could've eaten (and told them to tell everyone about it), so what did he expect to gain from his land grab? Makucha (in my opinion the best antagonist this show's yet had) was a one-off villain whose ousting didn't seem to impart any moral lesson, and the attempted ecology lesson with regards to invasive species was pretty poorly executed.
I won't go through all of the antagonists for the sake of everyone's time (including my own), but my point here is that it would be great for this already relatively mature show to introduce aspects of a moral grey area to its younger audience so that they don't develop a mindset in which people can just be labelled bad by definition, definition here being where they come from, and the Outlander cubs -- whom a good portion of the viewing audience already is sympathetic towards and know how they turn out in the end of Simba's Pride -- are a great vehicle for that.