by FlipMode » October 9th, 2011, 9:16 pm
[quote="Amanda"]
The point I'm trying to make though, is that he CREATED it. That would be like me stealing someone's OC and being like, "hurr I'll give it back when the owner returns.."[/quote]
Except nothing like it...
[quote="Amanda"]
Sure, he might have forgotten to give it to someone, and there might be no way of contacting him, but we should respect his ownership of it regardless.[/quote]
That is actually a fair point, although I would possibly argue the fact that this is only temporal and that if he does have an issue with it when, or indeed if he does return, then he can continue it his way if he would like.
[quote="Amanda"]
If you want to host a fanfic contest so bad, why don't you just make your own?
[/quote]
That is pretty much what I was trying to get at, surely hosting your own version of a pre existing contest that has temporarily ceased is pretty identical to taking over as host?
[quote="Amanda"]
It's not fair to snatch up someone's hard work word for word and claim it as "yours".
[/quote]
Is not what is going on here, nothing is being snatched nor am I claiming it is mine... Irrelevant point there, sorry.
[quote="Amanda"]
I'm sure Azdgari will be pretty disappointed to see that people have hijacked his fanfic contest when he returns. I know I'd be pretty mad.[/quote]
Well knowing him reasonably well, I wouldn't imagine he would be and would have the intelligence to understand that we are temporarily continuing it, not stealing anything. If he is, then hey I will apologize but lets just see, because the fact that YOU would be mad, does not mean anything, because you are not Az...
EDIT - Its happening anyway, so you can carry on arguing it if you want but it is pretty fruitless to do so, I asked several of the staff if this was okay before and they agreed with it, because yeah it would have been better to have asked him first but it really is not that big a problem as you (and me) are making it out to be.