Page 1 of 2

When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: June 7th, 2016, 1:19 am
by Elton John
... Was she being sincere or sarcastic? I think it could go either way...

Simba did take a big slice out of a hyena to buy her time to escape, and when the three hyenas were about to make a meal out of them simba planted himself in front of her, protecting her in the process. By doing this he put her safety first.

But nalas personality is a bit sassy and sarcastic, and she could have been sarcastic at his pitiful roar and how mufasa had to save the two.

Your thoughts?

Re: When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: June 7th, 2016, 1:49 am
by Captain Cupcake
She was being sincere. She was trying to make him feel better after Mufasa scolded him. The animation and delivery makes it pretty clear, and it's not really a situation where she could take a jab at Simba.

Re: When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: June 7th, 2016, 1:53 am
by Elton John
Captain Cupcake wrote:She was being sincere. She was trying to make him feel better after Mufasa scolded him. The animation and delivery makes it pretty clear, and it's not really a situation where she could take a jab at Simba.


Thank you. For the longest time I didn't know what she meant by it.

Re: When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: June 8th, 2016, 11:35 pm
by PrincessKiara
It was without a doubt a sincere moment where Nala was offering comfort and support to Simba.
When I saw the musical version in London however, some people laughed when Nala said this line - and I couldn`t understand why. It`s not a comical moment, she doesn`t say it as a joke, and Nala is right, Simba was acting very brave - and foolhardy, but showing courage nonetheless.

Re: When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: June 11th, 2016, 10:23 am
by Tsuki
When I was younger I thought she was being sarcastic I thought it was mean of her. Yeh kick him when he's down kind of thing. But now I do think she was being sincere :)

Re: When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: June 13th, 2016, 5:04 pm
by Carl
I always took it as sincere, she looks sad when delivering the line, and the tone of the scene is very somber. For it to be sarcastic wouldn't really make much sense. I mean she was obviously frightened of the hyenas, and Simba tried to protect her from them.

Re: When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: June 14th, 2016, 7:26 am
by Squeely
It was definitely sincere. Sure, Nala is sarcastic and playful at times, but she's also smart enough to know when it would be inappropriate to do so. Simba slashed Shenzi's cheek and stood in front of Nala, ready to protect her, even though both of them knew that protection likely wouldn't last for long. Nala's gonna give credit where credit is due, and it's quite clear that Simba was very brave from her perspective.

Re: When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: July 10th, 2016, 9:21 pm
by thechangingmyname
As a lil kid, I thought she said it to reproach him for failing to live up to his earlier bravado. As an adult, it seems she was being sincere.

Re: When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: July 12th, 2016, 6:58 am
by PridelandsPhantom
Even when I first saw it when I was eight I knew she was trying to comfort her friend who was upset and sad about being scolded by his father. She's basically saying "Don't be upset, you're my friend and you were brave." She wasn't being sarcastic but trying to comfort Simba who feels he's let down Mufasa and is scared of the repercussions of what will happen.

Re: When Nala says 'I thought you were very brave'...

PostPosted: July 15th, 2016, 4:09 pm
by Rachel-Lioness
I think it's more sincere then sarcastic. Given her expression during that scene. Makes sense with how brave Simba was acting.