My Lion King Forum

[quote="gothprincesskiara"]Now they are saying Scar wont be in the remake, please Im not the only who knows this is just a bunch of fake news[/quote]

Considering that Scar is the big villain of the movie, I am going to have to see some hard evidence before I even begin to suspect that this is Fake News.

You need to stop instantly believing every rumor you read, GPK.

I'm very curious who "they" are considering that the casting of Scar was highly publicized, first with the Hugh Jackman rumor that his agent/publicist had to shoot down, and then Chiwetel Ejiofor actually getting the role and showing up on the official main cast roster.

[quote="Elton John"]You need to stop instantly believing every rumor you read, GPK.[/quote]


I dont believe it at all its others who are believing it, I just want to make sure, i'm ot the only one here.

well, it sounds super fake.

it is already well known, like Pan said, that Scar has been casted in the movie.

It would be completely bizarre to write him out of the movie cuz they would need to completely rewrite the entire story all over again.

That would take far too much time and effort to do, and it makes little sense to do it.

So coincidentally I just happened upon a couple of different [uncited] sources that are purporting some potentially interesting changes to Scar, which might be where the new rumors of his "removal" are coming from. (Because any notable change to the characters in this film is being treated as destroying, ruining, or replacing the character altogether. And I thought superhero fanbases could be bad...)

According to this video -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=010-xSvOCeg which features an unlinked screenshot to text from a "dis insider dot com", which I was unable to find myself -- Scar might actually be
This I find genuinely surprising and quite interesting, and despite hyperbolic complaints of them changing the characters too much in every comment section I've seen outside of this forum (y'all are great), I actually really hope they go through with it.

considering the whole Kimba controversy I doubt it’s true. Unless the people working on the movie have no idea about the controversy, which is not only gross negligence on their part but disney as a whole.

If it is true. Hoo boy are we in for one heck of a lot of people claiming tlk copied Kimba again.

not to say that the lion king cant ever use a white lion character, it’s just an exceptionally terrible idea.

they can change Scar, without doing that. Do something bold with the character, not stupid with the character.

[quote="Elton John"]considering the whole Kimba controversy I doubt it’s true. Unless the people working on the movie have no idea about the controversy, which is not only gross negligence on their part but disney as a whole.

If it is true. Hoo boy are we in for one heck of a lot of people claiming tlk copied Kimba again.

not to say that the lion king cant ever use a white lion character, it’s just an exceptionally terrible idea.

they can change Scar, without doing that. Do something bold with the character, not stupid with the character.[/quote]

How much do you want to bet that, given with all the attention given to the whole "look at our ethnically black cast" marketing of the movie, that there will be an outcry at making Scar a "white villain"? I would so like them to leave Scar's design alone and not have to listen to PC whining from either side.

Call me jaded, but if they make Scar white, I'm calling it: there will be complaints about it, and for all the wrong reasons.

yeah

that’s another reason why it’s a bad idea.

there’s enough complaining about this remake as is, I don’t want more of it.

another important thing, brought up by Lindsay Ellis in one of her recent videos.

in the recent disney remakes of animated properties disney has gone out of their way to rectify complaints against the originals.

this would go against that.

Oh, there will definitely be complaints, and I'm going to laugh. He's already the only British-sounding lion in the series, then he's one of the few consistently white roles in the Broadway show (whereas most of that show's cast are usually black or other non-black POC; even in the South African casting he's played by a British dude). This wouldn't be too much out of step if you look at it that way, and people still love [to hate] Scar after almost 25 years.

As for the Kimba comparisons, if it's not a legality issue then I figure Disney is just confident enough that they'll at least get the money they want regardless of whether that comes up again. Heck, they're re-releasing the original film on 4K home release in December.

P.S. -- After one more search attempt, I found the source itself that originally published this: https://thedisinsider.com/2018/03/19/ex ... ng-remake/ It's actually from back in March, so presumably they've already made their decision by now and we'll find out soon, provided Scar appears in the trailer.